The First Scarlet Door
by J.D. Barker
Episode 45
How trying to trap James Patterson inside their own novel turned J.D. Barker from a pantser into a hardcore outliner.
Watch Now!
Listen Now!
Inside This Episode
J.D. Barker spent his early career as a strict pantser, writing more than half a dozen novels without an outline, when a phone call from James Patterson turned into an unlikely writing partnership. Patterson is a hardcore outliner who writes thirty to fifty pages of outline before starting a book, so the two agreed to try it Barker’s way first. They wrote The Coast to Coast Murders by pantsing it scene by scene, each one trying to trap the other in an impossible spot, sending new pages back and forth. The book ran to 170,000 words, with 50,000 to 60,000 cut before it worked.
Afterward, Patterson turned the tables and handed Barker a full outline for their next book, The Noise, which came together fast with almost nothing left on the cutting room floor. Barker calls it a turning point for how he approaches most of his own books since, though for this new prequel trilogy specifically he used a hybrid method, tracking the original series’ twists and dates on a notepad rather than building a full outline. He also talks about writing all three prequels in secret before showing them to his own agent, and how the trilogy is built to make longtime readers unlearn what they thought they knew.
Key Takeaways:
– Why he agreed to write a whole novel by pantsing before ever trying an outline with James Patterson
– How writing The Coast to Coast Murders by trading chapters back and forth shaped its twists
– Why one outlined book, The Noise, converted him from a lifelong pantser into a hardcore outliner
– How he tracked a decade-old trilogy’s twists and dates on a notepad to write this new prequel
– Why he wrote all three prequels in secret before showing them to his own agent
J.D. Barker | The First Scarlet Door: https://www.amazon.com/First-Scarlet-Door-4MK-Thrillers/dp/B0GKPN3YHV
Follow J.D. Barker online: https://jdbarker.com/
Want to be part of the conversation? Join the Patreon and ask your questions for the guest. You’ll also get early access to episodes and a free novella Cognitive Breach. Your support helps keep The Thriller Writer Lab going and brings more great thriller authors into the Lab.
https://patreon.com/markpjnadon
Mark’s Thrillers
Psychological tech thrillers from your host, including The Treatment Room: https://mybook.to/marksthrillers
Follow on Social:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/markpjnadon
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thethrillerwriterlab/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thethrillerwriterlab
Author Bio
J.D. Barker is the New York Times and international best-selling author of numerous novels, including SOMETHING I KEEP UPSTAIRS and the wildly popular 4MK thriller series. He regularly collaborates with James Patterson. His books have been translated into two dozen languages, sold in more than 150 countries, and optioned for both film and television. Barker resides in coastal New Hampshire with his wife, Dayna, and their daughter, Ember.
Transcript
TWL Episode 45 with J.D. Barker
J.D.: It was so much fun ’cause I’m basically trying to outsmart James Patterson. He’s trying to outsmart me, and it’s the twistiest book I’ve ever written. He’s a hardcore outliner. He writes 30 to 50 pages of an outline before he even starts writing the book. So I didn’t think we were gonna be able to work together, but to his credit, he took a step back and said, “You know what? I really wanna work with you.
Let’s try to do this your way. Let’s pants a novel.” I would write a scene and paint him into, what I thought was this crazy impossible scenario. I was like, “No way Jim’s gonna get out of this.” I would send him those pages and 15 minutes later, he’d send me new pages back.
He’d write like another chapter or two. Not only did he get out of it, but he put me in an even worse position, and we wrote the whole book that way.
then at the end he said, “You know what? We tried it your way. I want you to try it my way. He sent me this outline and we wrote that book based on his outline, and it went so quick and, very few words on the cutting room floor. We just, we knew where we were going. And it was one of those come to Jesus moments for me.
I realized that this might be the better way. So the short version of the story is I started off as a pantser. I am now a hardcore outliner.
Mark: Welcome to the Thriller Writer Lab, where every thriller goes under the microscope, one book at a time. I’m your host, Mark Nadon, and this is where best-selling, award-winning, and emerging thriller authors share the craft, research, and real-world experiences that power today’s most gripping stories.
Joining me today is New York Times bestselling author J.D. Barker, and we are putting his psychological thriller, “The First Scarlet Door,” under the microscope. J.D., thank you so much for being here.
J.D.: Hey, thanks for having me. I appreciate it
Mark: It’s an honor to have you as a guest, and thank you for sending the ARC copy. I really enjoyed your book
J.D.: Thank you. And so let me ask you a question. Did you read the original trilogy before or is this is the first time you’ve read anything in
Mark: This is the first time,
J.D.: Okay.
Mark: so I am jumping in late.
J.D.: yeah, no it’s a weird dynamic because, the original trilogy has been out for close to 10 years at this point. But it’s still selling really well.
It’s still coming out in new countries. It’s still hitting bestseller lists. It just got optioned for the fourth time. Sylvester Stallone’s company of all people picked it up, Balboa Productions which is fantastic. But when I sat down to write these, I wasn’t sure quite how this was gonna work because, I’ve got a series that’s existing.
I’m writing three prequels to that series. And with a numbering scheme that we used. For people that aren’t familiar with it, the original book is called “The Fourth Monkey.” When I turned in the second one, it had a totally different title, and my editor was like, “We should keep the numbering thing going.”
So the second one came out as “The Fifth to Die,” the third one came out as “The Sixth Wicked Child.” So I basically have books four, five, and six that have been out there for 10 years, and now I’m circling back writing one, two, and three. And it’s interesting to hear, the people that are reading them because the bulk of the world will read four, five, six, then go back and read one, two, and three.
Other people are like you and they’re coming into it fresh, starting at the beginning. As a writer, that’s a tricky thing because I needed to write it in a way that worked, regardless of where you jumped into the series. So I like to think I pulled it off, so it’s always nice to hear from somebody who’s doing what you’re doing.
Mark: Yeah, you did. You did very well, and we’ll get into like pacing and character and villains and all that stuff ’cause it was just, it was so well done. Absolutely, yeah I loved it. So let’s start with this is the first book in the prequel for the 4MK Trilogy. So tell me about the premise for this book, and if there’s anything I need to know about the trilogy heading in.
Obviously, I’ve read it without reading the trilogy, and it read very well, but if there’s anything that might help a, a listener
J.D.: Yeah, so it all came about organically I guess. When I wr- when I wrote The Fourth Monkey I knew I wanted to write a serial killer novel, but I didn’t wanna write the same novel that we’ve heard, you know, over and over again. This guy just pops up from nowhere as people start dying.
The police kinda jump on it. They follow him along. I basically wanted to do something different. So in my book, the killer’s been operating in Chicago for five years. Everybody knows who he is. He’s all over the press. They know his MO. He basically kidnaps a victim, he chops off her ear, and he mails that ear back to her family in a little white box tied with a black string.
That’s how he starts every one of his murders. So at the beginning of The Fourth Monkey, I’ve got a guy who’s crossing the street in Chicago. He’s walking to a mailbox about to mail a little white box tied with a black string, and he gets hit by a city bus and killed So the police, as soon as they get on scene, they realize this is our killer, we’ve got him.
But he’s got no ID on him, so they’ve got no idea who he act- actually is, and he’s got that little white box, so they realize he’s got a victim out there somewhere, but he’s dead. They have no idea who he is, who the victim is, or where she is, and that’s what basically creates the ticking clock that you need in any kind of thriller.
I wrote the first couple of chapters, I was flying along, and then I hit a wall. I realized, yet somehow, the killer needs to be active in this story, but he’s dead. What do you do? So I wrote a diary for the killer and the police basically find it on his body, and the diary flashes back to when he’s 15 years old and gives us a ton of insight into the killer himself because he’s telling that story in first person from his point of view.
So we flash back and forth between those, 15 y-years ago diary entries versus the present in the police procedural to keep the, the pacing going. So I wrote the all three books in the series basically like that. I end the final book, “Sixth Wicked Child,” he is still 15 years old. I end him in a, I tie up the bulk of the loose ends I still leave that killer there at 15, and he basically doesn’t start murdering people until he’s 30. That’s when the 4MK Killer basically surfaces in Chicago. So I had this 15-year gap. I felt it was okay because I wrapped up the full trilogy.
I was happy with it, I’ve been a- all over the world at this point, and people put these books down in front of me, and they constantly ask me, “What happened in those 15 years? What turned him from this 15-year-old kid to the guy who’s all of a sudden killing people in Chicago?”
I heard that so much. And when COVID hit I was ahead of schedule. The publishing industry only lets you put out like one or two books a year, and I write a lot faster than that, so I’ve got a bunch of books kinda sitting off to the side ready to go. I figured I’m gonna try something different.
I’m gonna write three prequels to the series, not tell anybody that I’m doing it because I’m not sure if it’s gonna work and just, kinda see what happens. And I locked myself in my office and I wrote the three prequels. It was honestly very refreshing because I got to pick up the storyline with him at 15, I got to take him all the way to 30, and basically show that evolution from a good kid to a serial killer, both mentally and physically and, everything that kinda pushed him along.
But as a writer, like I was able to do some really cool things. If I came up with an idea while I was writing book three, I could go back to book one or book two and, seed that idea, add whatever I needed to, to feed it later into the story. So I was able to get those three books very tight, which is something I wasn’t able to do with the original trilogy because they were being published as I was writing.
But I wrote all three books, I turned them into my agent, and here we are.
Mark: So the premise for this one then, can you talk a little bit about what it is that we’re facing here? He mentioned he’s 15. What’s kind of the plot?
J.D.: Yeah, I mean, one of the things I’ve been trying to answer with this entire series, I, in, in real life I got halfway through a psychology degree before I realized I didn’t wanna become a psychologist. I just really like studying people. But it, it brought a question to mind that I’ve been trying to answer with this series, and that’s can you take a perfectly ordinary person and turn them into a killer just based on the things that happened to him?
You know, events that happened in his life, the way people treat him that kind of thing. So that’s essentially what I was exploring with this story. And, you know, I tried to illustrate that with these, these three prequels ’cause we basically take him from, more or less an ordinary 15-year-old, and these things just keep happening to him over and over again that just push him to the point where he eventually cracks and, and goes over the edge.
It’s a very difficult thing to write because I, I wrote it all in first person, you know, from his point of view, so we’re in his head as these things are, are happening. So, you know, something… You know, I don’t wanna get too much into the details here, but like something bad happens, he reacts to it in his particular way.
I have to sell the reader on his reaction. Like, his reaction has to make sense, at least from his point of view, in, in a way where the reader understands why he’s doing it. If without doing that, you know, the, the whole thing kind of falls apart. But, but I, I think I did. I think I pulled it off. Well, we’ll find out very soon.
Mark: Did you outline this and do you have a book bible of the 4-MK? ‘Cause you know the destination, you’re writing before the destination. So do you have a story bible where you’re keeping track of everything you’ve said in the 4-MK series and, or trilogy, and then you come back for this one to write it and you’re trying to reference to make sure that you hit it all correctly and you don’t make up things that happened to him that didn’t necessarily happen in the future?
J.D.: Yeah, there was a lot of timeline stuff I had to stick to, you know, a lot of facts that happened, where I seeded the ideas in the trilogy, but, this happened long ago, this happened long ago. Now all of a sudden we’re in that long ago period, so I’ve gotta make sure those dates match up and the events match up.
So essentially what I did is I went back through the original trilogy and I read it as a reader with my notepad out, and anytime I ran into a twist, anytime I ran into any kind of date mark, any- anything like that I knew was a benchmark, I made a note of it and then when I went back to actually write, I made sure that I hit those dates and I made sure that they all made sense.
Which was, it’s not easy, when you’ve got a lot of them. You know, One of the other things I had to do is, like the original trilogy is extremely twisty. I had to take all those twists and flip it, basically on its head again because when readers go back into these prequels, I need to get them to unlearn everything that they’ve already learned.
Everything they accepted as fact all of a sudden I’ve gotta make suspect. So I try to write down as many of those things as I possibly could. I took, some things were very just ambiguous little, one paragraph here, one paragraph there of little things that happened, but I was able to take those and turn them into like an integral part of the story.
So when you read them the first time in the original trilogy, you gloss right over it. It doesn’t seem like anything. But when you read the prequels, you realize, “Holy crap, this was, very important. This happened and this is what happened because of that.” So like there are a lot of moving parts.
A- I’ve had a love-hate relationship with the whole outline, pantser kind of thing. you know, Like most authors, I read “On Writing” by Stephen King. It– there’s a bunch of books behind me. There’s only two on the process of, on, of writing. One is “Strunk & White”, which gives you all the, the elements of style.
It gives you all the grammatical stuff, and Stephen King’s “On Writing”, which basically tells you his process of what he does. And one of the things he tells you in that book is that he never, he’s what he ca- they call a pantser. He comes up with his scenario, his characters. He drops these people in the midst of whatever this crazy scenario is, and he just lets it play out.
He has no idea where it’s going, and he feels if he doesn’t know, the reader’s not gonna figure it out and it’s gonna be that much better for that. Um, So I ran into my first couple of books basically following that process as a pantser. About, geez, seven, eight years ago, I got a call from James Patterson.
Um, He had read my second book “The, The Fourth Monkey,” the first book in this, this series. And we got to talking about the idea of actually writing something together. And we went to lunch down in Palm Beach, and we were discussing it. Realized that, I was basically a pantser at this point.
I had six or seven novels that I had written that way. He’s a hardcore outliner. He writes 30 to 50 pages of an outline before he even starts writing the book. So I didn’t think we were gonna be able to work together, but to his credit, he took a step back and said, “You know what? I really wanna work with you.
Let’s try to do this your way. Let’s pants a novel.” So we wrote a book called “The Coast to Coast Murders,” and like I would write a scene and paint him into, what I thought was this crazy impossible scenario. I was like, “No way Jim’s gonna get out of this.” I would send him those pages and 15 minutes later, he’d send me new pages back.
He’d write like another chapter or two. Not only did he get out of it, but he put me in an even worse position, and we wrote the whole book that way. It was so much fun ’cause I’m basically trying to outsmart James Patterson. He’s trying to outsmart me, and it’s the twistiest book I’ve ever written. But when we got to the end, the book was about 170,000 words.
We had to take about 50 to 60,000 words out of that, to get it all to flow properly. So a lot of words ended up on the cutting room floor. But he was very gracious. He, went through that entire process and then at the end he said, “You know what? We tried it your way. I want you to try it my way.
Here’s an outline for a book called ‘The Noise.'” He sent me this outline and we wrote that book based on his outline, and it went so quick and, very few words on the cutting room floor. We just, we knew where we were going. And it was a, one of those come to Jesus moments for me.
I just, I realized that this might be the better way. I live on a little island off the coast of Portsmouth in New England, and every day I go for a run at 3:00, and I basically think about what I have to write the next day. And when I was pantsing a novel, I would use that time to figure out, what comes next?
But now if I have an outline in front of me, I already know what comes next, so I can use that same brain power to figure out how do I make what comes next better. And, the books have been much tighter ever since then. So the short version of the story is I started off as a pantser. I am now a hardcore outliner
Mark: Would you ever go back? Do you ever approach a new book and think, “This isn’t working, so I need to go back and do it the way I was doing it?” Is it do you flip-flop at all, or has it been since James Patterson in that moment.
J.D.: With these prequels, I kinda did a mix of both because I did the process that I told you, I just found all the twists and I made notes of that sort of thing, but I didn’t create an actual detailed outline of what the book was gonna be. I just made sure I had those benchmarks in front of me so that I hit them.
So it was a combination of pantsing and outlining. I, I am not afraid to go back and do one, one way or do one the other way. I’m constantly trying new things just to keep it fresh. You can’t really see it, but there’s a typewriter on the table back behind me there. Every day when I walk into my office, I type a sentence on this novel that I’m writing on this typewriter.
And it’s coming across as a very detective noir, you know, like ’50s-type novel because, that’s what you write on a typewriter, right? That just feels like the type of story that needs to come out of that device. I’ve got another book I’m writing on a notepad. I’m writing it out in longhand in first person.
And I’m finding that it’s a very personal story because you can’t get more personal than writing something out by hand in first person on paper. So I’m constantly changing it up. It keeps everything interesting, and I feel that by trying all these different mediums, it helps keep my voice fresh.
Mark: How many projects do you have going on at once, or how many did you have going on when you wrote this book? It sounds like you have a number of novels
J.D.: there, are a lot. And it, this is, partly me, I’ve got a form of autism called Asperger’s. And it allows me to manage a lot of things. I’m very good at managing patterns and products and product lines and things like that. So I’ve got no problem having multiple projects in the, in, in the works at the same time.
I, I think I’ve got 10 to 12 books that I’m working on right now. Some of those are solo titles. I’ve got another one I’m writing with James Patterson. I’ve got a bunch of co-authors that I’ve brought in to work on other projects, so I’m working on those too. And I honestly, I like having multiple things going on because if I get stuck on one particular project, I can put it aside and go work on this one over here.
And, that first project never leaves my mind. I’m always thinking about it. And then when I come up with what- whatever I need to resolve whatever problem I had, I can go back to it. You can’t start off in this industry, I don’t think, that way, but, I’ve been doing this for since, since 11 14, so 12, 13 years now at this point.
I’m far enough ahead book-wise where I’ve got, what they call trunk novels, so I can jump around a little bit. I don’t have to, I don’t have a de- a deadline on a particular book that has to be turned in next week that I have to finish. I’ve got all these different ones that I’m working on.
and I, And I’m in a weird publication space too because I’ve got my own imprint at Simon & Schuster now, so I can basically put out what I want whenever I want, which is another whole thing. But I’m not tied to that, that, the, the traditional world in the way most authors are
Mark: So how do you approach writing different characters? Do you not feel like I’m writing… If you have 15 characters on the go at the same time, do you not feel like who is who? Am I not– Am I writing the same character again? Does this character feel like the other character? How do you approach how do you, how you build these different personalities and make them feel all authentic in such, in so much writing that you do?
J.D.: I think a lot of it comes from my history. It I don’t know what you know about my background, but I worked as a book doctor and a ghostwriter for a little over two decades before I actually started writing my own books. And I wrote a ton of memoirs for other people, and I really think that’s where I learned to create characters because I would sit down with like a female politician, I would interview her for two or three days, get all these stories down.
She would tell me what she wants in the book, then I’d have to get her talking about the things she doesn’t want in the book, and like that’s the stuff that would actually end up in the book because that’s what everybody wants to read. But I would get two or three days worth of interviews, and I would take all those tapes back to my house, and I would have to basically write a book in first person from her point of view.
When you do enough of those, basically getting in the heads of other real people it teaches you how to create character. They were characters to me. So when I write a book in today’s world, I think about characters a lot. I spend probably more time on that than I actually do the actual story.
They have to be real people to me before I actually start writing that book. When I teach classes, I often tell writers, “If you take, five of your characters and put them in a room sitting across from you, you ask them all the same question, you should get five different answers.” No, no different than if you had five real people sitting across from you.
So when I’m writing a book, similar to what Stephen King had said, I come up with my plot and I take these people and I drop them in the middle of it, but because I know each of them so well, I know how each person is gonna react. If one thing happens to this particular character, if that same thing happened to a different character, their reaction would be different no different than people in real life, and that’s really how you have to approach it.
If you start writing a book and you just, you create these paper characters, it works at the beginning, but like you have to figure out who they are before you get to the finish line. And once you do figure out who you are, you need to go back and adjust the entire first half of the book until you get there.
Uh, A trick that I learned very early on, I used to take a lot of actors and actresses, and I would just plug them into a book. So I would, basically start writing and say this guy is just like Ben Affleck.” And when you do that, like I know what Ben Affleck looks like, I know his mannerisms, I know the way he speaks, I know the way he walks because I’ve seen him in so many different things.
So he is a real person to me as a character. And if I do that, I start the book that way, so the characters start off feeling a lot more real than they would if I just started with paper characters. But even there, I get a third into the book, halfway through the book, and that character develops a complete personality all on their own.
And once I lock that in, I go back and I adjust the beginning of the book to make sure that it’s consistent all the way through.
Mark: How much planning do you do of characters before you start writing the book? And then what– do you, do they become very different as you write to the point where they’re almost, as you realize the actions that they would take, you almost end up reworking them a little bit? Or are they pretty much who you set out when you started?
J.D.: They’re usually dialed in from the beginning, and it’s mainly because of the type of book I write. Most of my books take place over, sometimes a couple hours, sometimes a couple of days but it’s a very short amount of time, so there’s not really time for a real person to change, you know? so a character isn’t gonna really change, so that means they need to come into that scenario as a, fully defined individual in order for me to understand what they’re gonna say, what they’re gonna do, how they’re gonna react. If I’m not there, I don’t start writing the book yet.
I make sure I get them dialed in. Like my lead detective in the 4MK series his name is Sam Porter, and like I could take him and drop him to, at the entrance of Disney World, and I know what ride he’s gonna go on first. I know what he’s gonna eat for lunch. I know the name of his first girlfriend in high school.
I know his favorite song. I know everything about him. None of this stuff will really end up in a book, but that’s what it takes in order to, to get somebody to feel real on paper.
Mark: How do you keep track of that in your mind? Maybe it’s just part of the gift that you have that you can visualize. To say what ride he would go on at Disneyland is a detail I don’t think I’ve heard many readers or writers get into.
J.D.: Think about like your own best friend in real life or your spouse or your partner or your next door neighbor. Like, how well do you know these people? That, that’s how I think of the, the characters. I, for what better or worse, like I’ve got a really good memory.
So like keeping that kind of stuff straight and keeping it, all up here, it’s never really been a problem. The biggest problem I honestly run into is I’m 55 and I don’t forget a whole lot of stuff, so the attic feels like it’s very cluttered at this point. Like I need to make s- make some room up there, but it’s all still there.
Mark: So the pacing in this book I absolutely loved. In a lot of books that I read, there’s lulls and you hear– you see it in reviews where the, the lulls come out and they say “This is boring,” and maybe it’s a slow burn, which obviously you don’t write. But how do you tackle pace? And I was reading an article in the Rolling Stone that you wrote about revision and how like professional writers are really big revisers.
That’s where the magic comes from. So how much of w- like what you’re writing with pacing is in the first draft and instinctive, and how much is second draft where your editor brain, I guess we could say writer brain, editor brain, your editor brain takes over and starts making decisions about this moment was slow or this moment’s going too slow.
Oh, I’ve described too much here. This is… how do you come to terms with all that? How do you know how to pace it? ‘Cause it’s just so well written
J.D.: Pacing is it’s a weird thing. You have to have fast moments, you have to have slow moments. It’s almost like a rollercoaster. If a rollercoaster was just strictly a downhill slide the entire time, it wouldn’t be that much fun. It’s going up that gets you, it’s coming down, and then you get that little bit of a break.
So you kinda need that feel when you write a book. There’s a lot of little tricks you can do as an author to make that happen. So when you wanna speed up a scene, I start using very short clipped sentences. A lot of dialogue is cut, because if you think of a person, they’re running from somebody who’s chasing them with a gun, they’re not speaking in complete sentences.
They’re grunting, they’re breathing hard, they’re trying to get words out to whoever’s running next to them. You can communicate that on paper. So a fast-paced scene, everything is very short. There’s a lot of white space on that page. What that does is it causes the reader to feel like they are flipping those pages even faster because there’s, very few words, a lot of white space.
They really are flipping the pages faster, so that gets that adrenaline going. When you wanna slow something down, you create a big block of text. You slow it down, with the words. Your sentences aren’t five sen- five words long anymore. They’re, connected with an and in the middle or a couple of commas.
So you can control the pacing through things like that. Um, One of the things I also do is I credit a lot of this to my beta readers. Every time I finish up a book, I’ve got six different beta readers, and I give them all a printed copy of the book. I found a long time ago that if I give them a printed copy, I get much better notes than if I give them an electronic copy.
But one of the things I tell them to do is to mark any place where they close the book, and I don’t care if it’s because they’ve gotta pick up the kids from school, they’ve gotta make dinner, they’ve gotta go to work. I don’t care what the reason is. I just wanna know where they felt it was okay to close that book, and I make them mark that.
And also any place where they skim. If they’re going along and they find a section is, boring to them, I make them highlight it with a highlighter. So I get all these sections back. And then when I get the beta reader copies back, I take all six copies, I put them on my desk, flip to page one on all of them, page two on all of them.
I look for patterns, and if I see multiple people skimming in the same spot, if I see them closing the book in the same spot, I find some way to rewrite that to, to alleviate that problem. Something else that Patterson taught me, and it seems so basic when I look back on it, but, as an author, when you write a chapter, our mind automatically creates a beginning, middle, and an end.
We need closure, so we put that all down on paper. But Patterson and I, we go back through a lot of our chapters, and we’ll delete the last sentence. We’ll delete the last paragraph, maybe move it to the beginning of the next paragraph or the next chapter. But we take it out of that one, and what that does is it creates– You get rid of that closure by… and you create a mini cliffhanger, which causes somebody to have to turn that page to figure out what, what happens. And, if you do that enough, as a reader, before you realize it, you’ve read 100 pages, and you can’t put the book down.
Mark: Do you feel like over time you’ve gotten better at this, so the first draft is always has less pacing issues or less writing issues?
J.D.: Yeah, it’s like anything else. I always think of writing as, as very similar to going to the gym. Like there’s a writer muscle, and the more you use it, the stronger it gets. If you take a week off, it gets weaker again. You’ve got– you can’t lift as much. It’s all very similar to that.
But like I, I think I’m 20 books in at this point. It’s definitely way easier than it was with book one, but I could go back five books and look at what I wrote and I’d, I would’ve written it differently today. I would’ve done it different. It’s constantly evolving. Yeah I’m always learning.
One of the things Jim and I love to do is if I read something that, just actually surprises me, you know, I’ll tell him about it and he’ll read it, and vice versa, because it’s very difficult to surprise a thriller author. We’ve seen it all, at this point. But, like sometimes we stumble into a particular writer that is just different enough where it’s worth dropping everything and reading.
And I’m always learning. Like I’m a huge Stephen King fan, and when he comes out with a book, a lot of times I will read it first as a fan, and then I go back through it with a highlighter, and I look at everything that he did. He’s phenomenal at creating characters. He can create a fully fleshed out person in two or three sentences.
And I– One exercise I used to give writers is pick up one of his short story collections, highlight any place where he introduces a new character, those two or three lines, look at exactly how he’s doing it, ’cause it… There’s no magic to it. It’s, he’s very consistent in how he does it. But once you pick up on that, you can take that, that skill and you can roll it into your own writing.
So anytime a writer surprises me, if I stumble into something I’m not familiar with or I see them do something that is unique I make note of it and I try to incorporate it.
Mark: Awesome. So do you write with any themes in mind as you’re writing a story? Like any takeaways? When a writer puts down the book, are there any takeaways that you hope that they’re gonna feel or think about?
J.D.: I try not to. I don’t really wanna send a, a moral message or anything with a book but I think it happens anyway whether we want it to or not. I had a book a few years ago called “Behind a Closed Door,” and it’s about a husband and wife. They’re having marital problems, and they go to a therapist, and she recommends that they download an app called Sugar and Spice to basically spice up their marriage, and it’s essentially truth or dare for adults.
But the actual theme of the book was, what happens to the data, that, that’s collected on our phones? Who actually owns that data? It came about because my wife and I, we were talking one night over dinner, and she does a lot of real estate, and she had bought a house in Georgia.
And it’s a fairly large house, and we were talking about the renovations she had to do, and I think there were seven bathrooms. And I just casually suggested this company called Bath Fitters. We’ve all seen the commercials for them. But we were just talking about it over dinner, and then that night, we both noticed commercials for Bath Fitters start to show up on our phones and our social media feeds, on television.
So I dug a little deeper into that and realized in the terms of service for our phone, whether you’ve got an iPhone or an Android phone, you agree to the… allow them to listen to you 24/7. So my phone is sitting over here on the table. It’s listening to this conversation. It’s grabbing keywords out of the air, and it’s gonna use those keywords to send marketing data at me later.
That’s all happening on it in the background. So it got me thinking, what happens to all that data? Who owns it? What are they doing with it? So that was essentially it became a moral of this particular book, and people will read this book, and it’s extremely entertaining, but when they close it, the first thing they wanna do is shut off their phones and step away from technology because they realize what’s actually happening, in the background, the, the one thing that we don’t think about.
I’d s- so there’s a moral there, but it wasn’t in- intentional. I like to think I write literary popcorn. I just, I want people to just enjoy it. It’s almost like going to a movie. You just eat the popcorn, enjoy it. You don’t have to think about anything. It’s, just something to kinda distract you for a couple of hours.
Mark: Okay. ‘Cause with Anson, I felt like I’m learning how, we can judge people for who they become, but it’s almost like a question of, but where– who’s responsible for where they started? I guess was kinda like the theme that I felt when I was reading this. And Karin Slaughter wrote a book called “We’re All Guilty Here.”
That, that title has hit me every time I think about it because it applies to everything
J.D.: Yeah, it’s a great book. Yeah, Anson, I think just because I’ve, I’m telling this much larger story, that does creep in there.
Mark: Do you have any, what you think of yourself as like weaknesses in your own writing that you constantly have to kinda go back and correct? ‘Cause you, you probably know I’m good at, let’s say you’re good at dialogue and you’re good at pacing, but you’re not good at character development. I ju- I’m just throwing that out there. I don’t know
J.D.: Yeah, so a lot of it, Have you ever heard of a, a program called Autocrit? It’s a, a website. So I used to use that religiously and I love it. I still recommend it to authors. So you basically, you could take your text after you wrote it, could be a finished book, it could be a chapter or whatever but you can drop it into Autocrit.
There’s a tab on there called I think s- top writing or best writing, something like that. If you click on that and just go through the different things that it flags, it basically finds all the problems within your writing, so whether it’s passive voice or if you’re overusing particular words anything like that.
I used to run all of my books through that, and what I liked about it is it, all it does is redline it. It forces you to fix it, like it doesn’t actually fix it for you. And when you go through that process enough, it basically changes your writing style. You just, you don’t do that particular problem anymore.
I used to use the word it a lot and, then I would go back through and I would basically replace it with whatever it stood for. So it, delete it, I would write the gun, like that kind of thing. I used to use the word just quite a bit and it just, it subconsciously just crept out, so then I would go back through on the second draft and it’s one of those words you can usually just draw a line through it. It doesn’t need to be there but my brain, decided that it needed to be there on, on that particular draft. There’s always one thing I think like every book that just I tend to be, like I do repetitive i- in that, just in that one title.
And then I try to weed it out and then it’s gone, and then the next book has its own set of problems, and then those get weeded out and the next book has its own set of problems. There, there’s always something. When I wrote the second book in the 4MK series, it’s called “The Fifth to Die,” my wife was pregnant with our daughter and she had to give up coffee.
So in solidarity, I gave up coffee which is bad if you’re a writer. I wrote that whole book without drinking a cup of coffee, and then my editor called me when he read it and he’s like, “Do you have some kind of problem with coffee?” And I was like, “Why?” And he’s like, “You mention it throughout this entire book.
Charac- everybody’s drinking coffee. They’re all looking at empty coffee mugs. They’re looking at coffee machines.” And like that was all subconscious. That stuff creep, that stuff creeps out. You gotta watch for it
Mark: What about Nesbo?
J.D.: If there was one I haven’t found it yet. But it’s probably there
Mark: So you mentioned your wife. What’s the support network like for you, and not just your wife, but your support network in general from when you’re creating a book? You mentioned beta readers. How do you go about building, especially with, let’s say, “The First Scarlet Door,” how did you go about building it and the supports that are there to motivate you to keep going?
I know you’re- you do a lot of writing, so you’re prolific
J.D.: Yeah, I wouldn’t be writing today without my wife. She’s the one who gave me the kick in the pants. I don’t know if you heard this story, but, I was basically working a day job. I had been told early on that you can’t make a living as a writer, you have to get a real job. So I went off to college, I got a couple degrees, and I ended up working in finance, and I did that for two decades.
I hated every minute of it. But I would… Ultimately, I was a chief compliance officer at an investment banking firm down in Florida. It paid really well but because of that, I was stuck. I had that job for a long time, so we had all the trappings of that. We had a big house, we had cars, we had a boat.
So even though I hated that job, I knew I couldn’t just leave the job. Um, So my wife, to her credit, she came up with this crazy plan. We sold everything that we owned. We bought a tiny little duplex in Pittsburgh, rented out one side to some tenants, and we moved into the other side, and basically got to the point where we could live off of savings so I could write that first book.
And I remember sitting down at the kitchen table with her, and she showed me the bank statement, and she said, “Looks like you got about 18 months to, to crank out a novel and make it work before you have to get another job. Go.” And if she hadn’t given me that kick in the pants, I’d probably still be dragging my butt in, into work every day doing a job I absolutely hated.
I was 43 when we did that. It’s not easy to burn your whole life down and start over. So like you need a good support person, in your, in, in your life in order to be an author. And most of the writers that I know they, they all have that. It’s either their spouse or their partner. They’ve got somebody that they can depend on to help get them through all this.
Mark: You mentioned beta readers. Are there anyone else that reads your book building up to the
J.D.: got a pretty good stable at this point just because I’m doing a ton of co-author titles. I’ve got so many books in the pipeline, so I’ve got my beta readers, I’ve got editors that are on, on, on staff that are just reading and correcting stuff as we go. I’ve got copy editors. I’ve got two of them that I basically bounce books back and forth to.
I’ve got a good cover designer. I’ve got good formatters. I’ve tried some people. Some of them stuck around, s- other ones haven’t. I just, I feel like I’ve grabbed the best of the best. Uh, I mean, Just to give you an example, like the woman who booked this particular show, her name’s Kate.
I’ve had tons of PR people that I’ve worked with over the years. With my first book, I reached out to Dean Koontz, who I’ve known for a long time, and I asked him who he used for PR, and he gave me the name of this firm in New York, and I signed a deal with them. I gave them 20 grand as a, a retainer.
And the first month they got back to me and they’re like we got you three blog reviews and, these two mentions.” And I’m thinking, “$20,000 gone and this is what they got.” And most of these PR people are like that. Publicists just, they work on a retainer, they work on an hourly rate or whatever, but there’s no guarantee for any type of result.
So I changed that very early on. All of my PR people they’re basically on an a la carte basis. So like the woman who booked this show, she gets paid for every podcast that she puts me on. But she only gets paid for the podcast she puts me on. So she can hustle and she can make a lot of money or she can drag her feet and make little money.
But, everybody in my life I’ve structured it, from a business standpoint like that. Like they, they have to be productive or they’re not part of the team.
Mark: Ah, cool. Oké So this book, the f- it’s a four MK series that’s been optioned for television, right? So congratulations. That’s amazing ’cause I’m sure this is gonna blow up big when the TV show comes out. Did you know that before you, you started writing this and was there any pressure to write even a greater book?
Did you feel it as a writer that I have to nail this prequel because the opportunities could be enormous?
J.D.: Um,
No this, this is actually the fourth time that the series has been optioned. It was optioned before the f- “The Fourth Monkey” when that was going out to publishers. We got a film and a TV deal through CBS. So it was optioned before I actually signed the first publishing deal on it. But that basically came and went like nothing ever happened.
Then it got picked up by Lionsgate. They had it for a couple of years and nothing happened. Somebody else stepped up for a couple years, nothing happened. Th- this is actually the first time where I feel like it actually is gonna happen ’cause Sylvester Stallone’s company, they basically don’t take anything on unless they feel they can get it to the screen.
And they brought in this woman named Channing Powell. So if you’ve watched “Walking Dead,” she was basically the puppet master behind all those different “Walking Dead” series. And she came on as showrunner and lead writer on the 4MK series. So she’s the kind of person who can get all of this done.
So all of that’s, it’s definitely, makes me feel like it’s gonna happen. When I was negotiating that deal with my agents, I was writing the three prequels. We didn’t tell Balboa that I was writing three prequels, just like I, I didn’t tell anybody because I wasn’t sure if I was gonna like them and I didn’t wanna put them out into the universe until I was, 100% happy with them.
So that was a little happy surprise. We signed that deal and then I said, “Oh, by the way, we’ve got these,” which changed the dynamic of how they wanted to do everything, and they’re very much on board with doing the, the entire series, including the prequels. But I, I knew something was gonna happen with those.
I’ve been really lucky. I’ve got eight different projects in what I call various stages of Hollywood Hell, so I’ve had a lot of stuff optioned. Nothing’s actually been filmed yet. Somebody once told me if you watch the credits at the end of a movie, five or six minutes of all these names going by, if you take one of those names away, it’s like a house of cards that just kinda comes apart.
Everybody there had to be there in order for that thing to get to the screen. And that’s very much how it is in real Hollywood. It’s like this perfect storm has to come together before something actually, gets, gets done. But I had, a lot of stuff got optioned. I think I was on my fourth or fifth book.
I was writing a book called “A Caller’s Game,” and I got a little cocky. I’m like, “I’m gonna write a book that they can’t possibly film. I just wanna see what happens.” So I blow up like half of New York in this book. I’m like, “There’s no way they can film this.” As soon as my agent put it out there, Ridley Scott’s company picked it up.
They’re like, “Oh, hell yeah, we can film that. It’s gonna be expensive, but we can film it.” you know, So there’s just… you just n- you never know. I keep my nose to the, the desk and just keep writing the next book. Hollywood stuff is very odd. You know, like When I get a phone call from my film agent, it’s either really good news or really bad news.
Like there’s no in between with those guys. And it can be very distracting, so as a writer, your best bet is just to write that next book
Mark: Yeah. Okay. Going back to characters for a minute, how do you write… In this book, there are essentially, depending on how you view the characters, it’s almost a book filled with really bad villains and villains we’re kinda trying to understand. How do you approach that when you’re building characters? Do you feel like every character is, like, a villain who’s just under these awful circumstances?
J.D.: No, I mean, I, I try to treat it like real life. you know, Bad guys to me, they don’t exist as like black or white. I think everybody on this planet works somewhere in that gray area, somewhere in between. We’ve all got good in us, we’ve all got bad in us. And I try to keep that in mind when I write these.
Like, If you read “The Fourth Monkey,” the first time we meet Anson Bishop, you close the cover of that book and you feel bad for the serial killer, like more so than the actual victims. And like it’s, that was an intentional thing. I worked really hard to bring that, that feeling across.
I want, I wanted the readers to feel empathy for them. So I try to keep that in mind as, as I’m writing. But, y- you could take the– you could go out into the street and find the nicest person in the world, and if you dig into their history, you’re gonna find something really dark and vice versa.
There’s every- everybody’s got good, everybody’s got bad and I try to put it all down on the paper.
Mark: Yeah. What about The Quick in this as almost it almost feels like a character ’cause it’s like a place where, the unwanted, undesirable kind of forgotten people end up coming together. It feels like it’s a sense. It has its own character. Did you build The Quick like a character in your mind or is it just a place that you researched and put
J.D.: it’s a little, it’s a little bit of both. So I’ve only been to Charleston. This takes place in Charleston South Carolina. I’ve only been there once. Um, And The Quick is basically a place I made up. The marketplace that it’s based on is real. So like you can walk down the street, you can stand in front of it, you can go on Google and you can find it.
The Quick is a place that I made up that basically exists on top of it, on the second floor of this existing marketplace. And I just I did it in a way where it feels probable. If you were to walk down the streets of Charleston today and you pointed up at it, it looks like it could possibly house what I basically said is there.
Places to me have always felt like characters. I’ve written haunted house books before, and like the haunted house to me like has to live and breathe. Like it needs to be part of that story. And cities are very much like that too. If you look around at any particular city, they’ve got a personality to them.
Chicago feels very different from New York. They both feel very different from LA. You go to New Orleans and it’s a completely different environment, and it’s different in the daytime versus at night. I try to pick up on the sights, the smells, the things, you know, ev- everything that’s going on and incorporate that into the story. It, I think it helps ground the reader, just makes everything more, more real to them.
Mark: So is every place you’ve written about essentially somewhere you’ve gone so you know what it, what that vibe feels like to write it as authentic as you can?
J.D.: Yeah, it’s either a real place or it’s, a combination of real places if I make up some place fictitious
Mark: Okay. And do you approach that just like you do characters if you’re making it fictional, or you’re asking
J.D.: Yeah I think you have to if you want it to become part of the story. Like if you’re gonna write a story in, like LA, for example, like the streets of LA have a very definitive feel to them. It is very much alive. I don’t think you can gloss over that and write a book that takes place in LA without bringing that feeling in there.
If you read like a Michael Connelly story you’re gonna understand what I’m talking about. And New York, very, like the gritty streets of New York, like the, Park Avenue is very different from this part, different from Brooklyn, different from here, different from there.
I, I think it’s important to bring all those elements in there. If you start glossing over all that kind of stuff, you just do like the 30,000-foot view, all of a sudden the location doesn’t feel quite real. Chances are if you’re doing that to the location, you’re also doing it with your characters, so your characters don’t feel quite real.
And before you know it, the reader is getting bored. They’re 10 pages in and they don’t have anything to root for, and they move on to the next book
Mark: What advice would you give to someone who just published their first or second book?
J.D.: I tell everybody they need to write every day. I mentioned the writer muscle, like I feel like that’s very important. I was working 60 to 80 hours a week in the corporate world and still cranking out novels, so it, it can be done. If you write 200 to 300 words a day, that’s a full novel within a year.
Your voice is gonna be fairly consistent from that first page to the last page. If it takes you four or five years to get a novel done, it’s great, you’re still gonna get to the finish line, but you’re gonna find you’ve got a lot of work to do on the editing front to make that feel like a concise story because it did, it was written over such a long period of time.
Um, The other thing I tell people all, is just you’re gonna hear no a lot. You’re gonna have a lot of people close doors on you. You’re gonna have people, give you negative reactions, a lot more so than positive. Agents are gonna say no, editors are gonna say no, film and TV people are gonna say no.
You just have to dust off, get back up, and just keep trying. You can’t let it get to you. You have to, that thick skin and just, keep moving on.
Mark: Yeah, I like that. How do you know though when I have a thick skin and I believe in this project, and this project isn’t where it needs to be to get the attention that I want it to get?
J.D.: That, that’s a really good point, and I think a lot of writers tend to gloss over that. I run into a lot of authors where they write a book, they go out, they query a whole bunch of agents, they get a bunch of rejections, and they say I’m just gonna put it up on Amazon and see what happens.” That’s the worst thing you could do.
What you really need to do is take a step back. First of all, realize that your book is now a product. It’s a widget that somebody else has to sell, so you have to turn that product into the best possible product. So reach out to those agents, try to find out why they were rejecting it, and if you can get a couple of them to tell you, there’s a very good chance it’s something that you could fix, so you could weed it out of the story and you can make that story better.
I really think every book needs to be a five-star read before it comes out. You shouldn’t put a book up on Amazon as an indie author unless it was just, it was good enough where it could have come out through the traditional world and you just decided not to. You decided the indie route was a better route for you.
But that should be the decision. It shouldn’t be because the traditional world turned its back on you or said no. It should be because they wanted it and you decided to go in another direction. If you go the other way, if you take a book that, got all these rejections, you don’t change anything, you just put it up on Amazon, the same thing always happens.
That book comes out, your friends and family read it. They give you… you get 10 or 20 glowing reviews from people that know you. Then all of a sudden the real readers find it. They start pointing out all the things that are wrong. The grammar is terrible. There’s punctuation problems.
This is going on, that’s going on. All of a sudden your five-star rating goes down to two and a half. You’re sitting at a million and a half in the Kindle Store, and that book is dead in the water. And, meanwhile, hopefully you’re writing your next book, but your next book is gonna have the same problems as the first book because you didn’t realize they were problems you had to begin with.
So your next book basically comes out. You send that off to agents. Agents are gonna get that book. It’s gonna have the same problems again, and worse, now if they Google you, they’re gonna see the results on that first book. They s- they see the sales records, they see the performance, they see the rating, and that becomes who you are to the rest of the industry.
It gets carved in stone. You can keep all of that from happening just by making sure that your book is as good as it could possibly be before you pull the trigger on it
Mark: Any advice for how to make it as good as it can be from in– let’s say before the agent, if you’re, some people will hire editors, some people will look for beta readers, but then you have the conflict of, beta readers give conflicting advice. Someone who thought this was fantastic, another thought this needs work here, and, there’s all kinds of feedback that may– could be great and it’s not, and it could be bad and it’s not,
J.D.: I make sure that my beta readers are all very different people. They’re not… None of them are writers. I prefer to find people that are actually readers, people that read a lot of books. Those are the people that I want reading my books as a beta reader. One of my beta readers gave me my very first one-star review on my first book.
And she had this long review on Amazon where she explained everything that was wrong with the book, and back then, this was very early on, they actually gave you email addresses for the people that left reviews so I could contact them. I reached out to her and I said, “Listen, if you take that review down, I’ll let you be, a beta reader on my next book as long as you give me that same kind of feedback.”
So I accomplished two things. I got rid of that negative review, and I adopted a beta reader who’s still with me today. Another beta reader I have, she’s autistic like me but she’s got this really cool skill where if she reads a sentence on page 13 and I use the same phrase on page 342, she’ll remember it and she points it out.
So I’ve got, basically six different people that approach those books from different parts, different ways and give me different feedback. I think that’s very important. Y- fe- reader feedback is by far the most crucial thing I think you can get. I always make sure before my agent sees a book, it’s already gone through the editing process.
I’ve already hired copy editors to make sure it is as clean as it could possibly be before the agent sees it, definitely before an editor sees it. And what you’re gonna find happens is, the feedback you’re gonna get from these people is gonna be a lot more positive and you’re more likely gonna get a lot more money if an editor offers on it because now they’ve got a book in front of them that needs very little work.
They don’t have a whole lot of time, so if they can take on a project, they will pay more for something that, that doesn’t need work
Mark: Yeah. Okay. That’s awesome. That’s great advice. Yeah. I have a question from Angela Douglas, the last guest on the show, and we come to an ask it forward. She asks, “Where did you get the idea for the 4MK trilogy?”
J.D.: Uh, That comes back to what we talked about at the beginning. I knew I wanted to write a serial killer book, but I wanted it to have a twist and do something different from the, the other serial killer books that were out there. So as soon as I realized if I kill my killer at the beginning of the book, I’ve got something brand new that nobody’s seen yet I was off to the races.
Mark: And where can listeners find out more about you and follow you online?
J.D.: Easiest place to find me is jdbarker.com. I’m on all the social medias @jdbarker, and the books can be found in any bookstore
Mark: And finally, what’s one question you’d like me to ask the next author that comes on the show? The next author is Karen Osborne. She wrote “Getting It Right.” It is a psychological thriller about a woman who is searching for her half-sister that her dying father abandoned 24 years ago. As the two sisters try to build a trust, a dangerous secret pulls in federal agents, and what starts as a search for family becomes a fight for the truth
J.D.: Um,
One of the things I love to do is write multiple endings. And I’m just curious if any other authors actually do that. So a-ask her if she has another ending other than the one that appeared in the book
Mark: Okay, awesome. I will ask that. Thank you so much. This has been wonderful. J.D. Barker, “The First Scarlet Door.” Read it. Leave a review. Thank you for listening or watching, and have a wonderful day
J.D.: Thank you so much. Appreciate it.
